8 Long Puffer Coats That *Actually* Hold Up in Sub-Zero Degrees, According to a Person Who’s Lived in the Coldest Regions in the U.S.

18 years in Chicago, four years in Wisconsin, and two years in Boston: I can safely say that I've lived in some of the coldest (and snowiest) regions of the U.S., where temperatures frequently dip below zero during wintertime. While layering and bundling up with scarves and gloves has helped a ton, there's no layer more important than a long puffer coat, which can help you get through frigid temperatures (brrrrr). Compared to regular puffers, the best long puffer coats insulate more areas of the body, retaining more warmth in the legs (yes, protecting your legs does matter) and shielding out the cold from your bum. That's why they're constantly in my winter wardrobe.

The best long puffer coats, at a glance:

• Best overall: The North Face, Women's Arctic Parka, $350
• Best extra long: Lands' End, Down Maxi Winter Coat, $290
• Best sport: Lululemon, Wunder Puff Long Jacket, $398
• Best eco-friendly: Tentree, Cloud Shell Long Puffer, $328
• Best luxury: Canada Goose, Byward Parka Pastels, $1,295
• Best fit: Aritzia, Super Puff Long, $350
• Best stain-resistant: L.L. Bean, Ultrawarm Coat, $299
• Best non-boxy: Patagonia, Down With It Parka, $350

What to look for in a long puffer coat

When looking for a puffer coat, watch out for the fill number, which usually ranges between 500 and 700. The numbers matter because the higher the number, the loftier the jacket and the more efficient the feathers are at retaining warmth. You'll also want to look for a water- and resistant-fabrics like polyester and nylon to shell out snow and rain for when things get slushy.

We know there is a plethora of jackets on the market, so we researched and tested some of the best long puffer coats. Ahead, you'll find our top picks that'll prepare you for bone-chilling, sub-zero days.

The best long puffer coats

How to choose the right long puffer coat for you

Consider the fill

Whether the fill is made of down feathers or synthetic alternatives, the higher the count, the warmer the coat. All of the picks on our list are at least 600-fill, which makes them suitable for cold winter days (30-40 degrees Fahrenheit). If you're going to be spending time in even colder temps, you might want to opt for a coat with a higher fill, like the Canada Goose pick on our list.

Resistance to wind and water

The only thing worse than being cold is being cold and wet (oh joy!). Consider the typical winter weather in your area. If it's typically windy (like Chicago) or super wet (hello, Seattle), you'll want to opt for a coat with a wind and water-resistant outer shell.

Your preferred materials

While there are plenty of companies that ethically source their down fill, folks who want to avoid animal byproducts entirely may have a tougher time finding a long puffer coat that actually keeps them warm. Luckily, there are a few brands on our list that use recycled down (Patagonia) or down alternatives (Tentree) without compromising on insulation.

Your unique body type

Long puffer coats are a big purchase, so it's important to make sure the fit is just right. If you're someone who regularly shops for short, tall, petite, or plus sizes you'll want to opt for a brand with more options. On our list, The North Face and Aritzia shine in that department.

Added features

Cinched waists, deep pockets, detachable hoods, two-way zippers—all the little details add up when you're shopping for a long puffer coat. Take stock of what each coat has to offer (and consider whether it's something you'll actually use) to help narrow down your options.

Frequently asked questions

Should you size up or down for puffer jackets?

Ideally, you should be able to wear the same size puffer jacket as your other jackets. But, if you tend to be between sizes, it's always best to size up for outerwear. Long puffer coats are intended to keep you warm, but you'll likely be wearing thick layers underneath as well. You'll want to be able to bend down and tie your shoe with ease, or zip your puffer jacket up over a cable-knit sweater. Whether you're shopping in a store or trying on your new coat at home, make sure you're wearing a thick base layer so you can get a true feel for how the coat fits over warmer clothes.

Are puffer jackets worth buying?

Like all clothing purchases, whether puffer jackets are worth buying is a matter of personal preference. If you live in a place with cold winters (or just get cold easily), these fluffy, insulated coats can be a huge help. However, if you're not keen on the look of a puffer coat, you can likely still stay warm with a wool peacoat and some warm base layers.

How can you tell if a puffer jacket is good quality?

The brands on our list sound familiar for a reason—most are leaders in the outerwear game and have been for decades. Still, there are several newer brands (Aritzia, Tentree) that have followed suit with quality designs. As a general rule, high quality puffer jackets will have a higher fill count (600 and up) and the brand will be transparent about what the fill is and where it's sourced from. They'll also have thoughtful details like adjustable waists and hoods—which contribute to keeping cold wind at bay—and multiple pockets for your gloves, keys, and phone. And, unfortunately, they'll likely cost you more money. Still, if you consider the fact that a quality jacket will last several winters, it's usually worth the investment.