Finding the best gifts for Scorpios isn’t for the faint of heart. These intense, brooding creatures don’t want your basic, half-baked presents—Scorpios can feel if you didn’t put your soul into the gift. Ruled by Pluto (the planet of transformation, death, and all things dramatic), these water signs thrive on mystery, depth, and a little edge. So, if you’re thinking of going the safe route with a generic candle or something cute this Scorpio season (which runs October 23 to November 21, FYI), stop right there.

“Scorpio is one of the most complex energies of the zodiac,” says astrologer Patty Kamson. They brim with dark-horse energy and have interests as enigmatic as their personalities. They’re usually drawn to all things mysterious and taboo such as the supernatural and occult, which only adds to the sign’s mystique.

“Anything witchy and woo and weird is their vibe” —Jana Stern, astrologer

“Anything witchy and woo and weird is their vibe,” adds astrologer Jana Stern. Beneath the seemingly stoic appearance, Scorpios are also very much in tune with their feelings. These water signs are masters of self-reflection and aren’t afraid to delve deep into the depths of emotions. “Any kind of metaphysical book that allows them to see and understand themselves is a good gift idea,” says Kamson.

At their core, Scorpios are incredibly empathetic. “They feel so much,” says Kamson. “Being able to take time to step away to heal and release everything that’s been caught up in their own energy space is really important because Scorpios hold onto stuff.” Things like beautiful journals and other self-care essentials will keep Scorpio’s deeply sensitive souls happy and nourished.

Our moody scorpions also crave connection and intimacy—not only emotionally, but also physically. “Scorpio is kind of known—okay, not kind of—very known for their high sex drive,” says Stern. (The sign is associated with the genitalia and the eighth house of sex and taboo, after all). As such, anything that indulges their passionate side is sure to please. (Think: lingerie, massage oils, and sex toys.)

Ultimately, Scorpios appreciate it most when a gift speaks to their particular interests. “When in doubt, look at what they have and what they already love,” says Alex Caiola, astrologer and founder of Capricorn Rising Inc.—the latter of which you’ll find in the list ahead. With all this in mind, read on for the best gifts for Scorpio signs. If you’re looking for gifts for other zodiac signs, see our gifts for Libra and gifts for Sagittarius.

Shop the best gifts for Scorpios

The Wild Unknown Tarot Deck and Guidebook — $22.00

Get the Scorpio who is drawn to the occult this enchanting tarot deck, which comes recommended by Caiola. Its 78 cards incorporate animals and nature through its stunning. It also comes with a practical and supportive guidebook that offers a more detailed explanation of the cards—perfect for the Scorpio who wants to get more in touch with themselves at a deeper level.

Flewd Rage Squashing Soak (Set of 3) — $26.00

Scorpios value their alone time—and a good bath provides a safe, private, and relaxing space for them to brood in peace. Flewd’s Rage Squashing Soaks can make their bath time that much restorative. Made with magnesium, chromium, and vitamin B12, and beautifully scented with jasmine and cedarwood, they can help to release pent-up emotions that have been bubbling under the surface.

Komal’s Handmade Leather Journal — $19.00

Despite their calm and cool facade, Scorpios feel all the feels—and a journal can help to release nagging thoughts and hold their innermost secrets. “Journals make very good gifts because Scorpios are very guarded with their emotions and they keep how they feel close to the chest,” says Kamson. This 100 percent leather-bound journal gives major Scorpio energy: it looks like it could be used to write spells by candlelight. It features 240 unlined pages made from recycled cotton that is wood- and acid-free, and its leather strap adds an extra touch of edgy style.

BestSelf Co. Self Journal — $40.00

Scorpios are never without a plan. “They always have a plan B, C, D, and E, because they’ve got to have the backup when things inevitably go wrong and they have to burn it all to the ground and start over again,” says Stern. If you want to give them a journal with a little more direction, the BestSelf Co. Self Journal can help track big-picture goals. It’s designed to be used in a 13-week sprint and features weekly and monthly pages that make it as useful for daily planning.

"Pluto: The Evolutionary Journey of the Soul" by Jeff Green — $28.00

Pluto: The Evolutionary Journey of the Soul supplies astrological methods and techniques to understand how Pluto plays a role in one’s life and helps to uncover answers to existential questions. The book, plucked from Caoila’s bookshelf, allows for reflection and self-understanding from an astrological point of view—which by all counts is “so Scorpio,” she says.

Quiet Mind Weighted Stress Ball Mini Squeeze — $64.00

Scorpio’s secretive nature often leads them to bottle up their emotions, and if they won’t confide in others, this weighted stress ball can help serve as a healthy release. It can be hugged or squeezed—perfect for when they’re feeling all wound up.

HigherDOSE Infrared PEMF Go Mat — $699.00

Being a fixed water sign, Scorpios have a hard time letting go. Help them clear any emotional buildup and tension that needs releasing with this PEMF mat. Using charcoal, clay, magnetic, and crystal therapies, the mat is designed to mimic the vibrations of the Earth to boost the body’s natural recovery process. It’s a pricey gift, but it’s one to help them stay grounded no matter where they go.

Tom Ford Oud Wood — $270.00

If the Scorpio in your life is in search of a new signature scent, why not select one based on their zodiac sign? “They like scents that are woody and musky,” says Kamson. With that in mind, “Oud Wood”—which blends oud wood, sandalwood, amber, and vetiver—is the perfect pick. It’s sensual, sultry, and leaves a lasting impression, just like your favorite Scorpio.

Quince 100% Mongolian Cashmere Woven Fringe Scarf — $60.00

This Quince scarf makes a great gift for a beloved Scorpio. For one, “They love black,” says Kamson. Secondly, according to Stern, “They like good fabrics.” Made from 100 percent Mongolian cashmere and available in a classic black color, it ticks all the boxes. Plus, it’s large enough for a Scorpio to bury themselves into when they want to go incognito.

Calzedonia No Drama 30 Denier Sheer Tights — $25.00

These sheer tights make a statement, and given Scorpio’s typical flair for the bold and brazen, the pair will appeal to the zodiac’s passionate—and yes, sometimes, dramatic—sign.

Natori Ashley Icon Robe — $130.00

This robe from Natori is made from silky-smooth satin and features lace details that add a hint of sexiness, making it just the thing for sensual Scorpio. They’ll be chuffed by its sumptuous feel and the fact that it’s created in the color black will earn you bonus points in their books.

Govee RGBIC Floor Lamp — $100.00

Featuring millions of possible color combinations, this lamp will suit Scorpio’s every mood—and, not to mention, will add a touch of moody ambiance totheir living space.

Bond Touch Long Distance Touch Bracelets — $138.00

As one of the zodiac’s most sensual signs, physical touch is definitely Scorpio’s love language. If you live miles apart or are temporarily out of arms’ reach, this pair of long-distance bracelets can help close that gap. Touch one and the other vibrates, so you can ensure a far-away Scorpio partner, BFF, or relative can feel your love at any given moment.

Lelo Flickering Touch Massage Candle — $25.00

This sensual massage candle has the scent of black pepper and pomegranate, offering a spicy underworld vibe. According to mythology, Hades—the underworld god after which Scorpio’s planetary ruler was named—used a pomegranate to seduce his bride Persephone. He gave her six seeds, which bound her to the underworld six months out of the year. When burned, the candle transforms into a massage oil that can be poured directly onto the skin.

The Pleasure Parlor The Zodiac Box: Scorpio — $75.00

A mystery pleasure box tailored specifically to their star sign? Yes, please. It’s packed with toys and other goodies for solo or partnered play, each handpicked with the help of astrologer and tarot expert Katie McGuire. Its contents aren’t explicitly specified, but that can make it all the more enticing to curious Scorpios.